Cozy mysteries have been a beloved genre for decades, offering readers a perfect blend of comfort and mystery. These stories often take place in quaint, charming settings with relatable protagonists, and focus on the unraveling of a puzzling crime. But what happens when these cozy tales take a turn towards the paranormal? That’s where the real fun begins. In this article, we’ll be taking a look at the top 8+ cozy mystery books for 2025 that delve into the world of witches, ghosts, and other supernatural elements.
1. “The Witch of Willow Creek” by Sarah Addison Allen
In this enchanting tale, we are introduced to a small town in North Carolina, where the residents believe in the power of magic. Our protagonist, Stella, moves to Willow Creek to start a new life and ends up getting caught in a centuries-old mystery involving a witch’s curse. With the help of a handsome ghost, Stella must unravel the truth before it’s too late. This book will keep you on the edge of your seat with its perfect blend of mystery, romance, and a touch of the supernatural.
2. “The Haunting of Mavis Lovejoy” by Kaye Umansky
Mavis Lovejoy has always been an eccentric character, but no one in her small town of Little Broomstick knows just how eccentric she truly is until her death. It’s then that her granddaughter, Tabitha, discovers that Mavis was not only a witch but also a detective. Tabitha inherits her grandmother’s detective agency and takes on her first case – solving Mavis’s own murder. This clever and quirky book will have you laughing, gasping, and maybe even believing in magic.
3. “Murder at the Mill” by M.B. Shaw
When Iris Grey inherits her estranged grandfather’s mill in the English countryside, she sees it as an opportunity to start fresh. But her plans are put on hold when she discovers a dead body on the property. With no one else to turn to, Iris enlists the help of her good friend and amateur sleuth, Hazel. As the two dig deeper into the murder, they uncover secrets that have been hidden for decades. This book is a perfect mix of a charming setting, intriguing mystery, and a touch of the supernatural.
4. “The Ghost and Mrs. McClure” by Alice Kimberly
In this book, we are introduced to Penelope Thornton-McClure, owner of the Buy the Book bookstore in Rhode Island. When a famous author dies in her store, Penelope finds herself communicating with his ghost. Together, they attempt to solve the mystery surrounding his death. This book has everything a cozy mystery lover could want – a lovable protagonist, a charming setting, and a ghostly sidekick.
5. “Murder in the Mystery Suite” by Ellery Adams
In this first installment of the “Book Retreat Mystery” series, we meet Jane Steward, owner of Storyton Hall, a book-themed resort. When a murder occurs on the premises, Jane must put her sleuthing skills to the test to clear her family’s name. With the help of her book club, she uncovers the dark secrets of the resort’s past and the truth behind the murder. This book is perfect for book lovers who also enjoy a good mystery.
6. “The Witch and the Dead” by Heather Blake
Darcy Merriweather comes from a long line of witches and has recently discovered her own powers. She moves to Salem to start a new life and ends up opening her own bookstore. But when a murder occurs in the town, Darcy’s powers and her knowledge of the paranormal come in handy as she sets out to find the killer. This book is a perfect mix of witchy charm, small-town gossip, and a chilling mystery.
7. “The Ghost Hunter’s Daughter” by Caroline Flarity
This young adult mystery follows Abby, whose father has a successful career as a ghost hunter. But when her father is murdered, Abby must take over the family business and unravel the secrets of her father’s past. This book is not only a captivating mystery, but it also explores themes of family, grief, and the supernatural.
8. “The Haunting of Beatrix Greene” by Rachel Hawkins, Ash Parsons, and Vicky Alvear Shecter
Fans of historical fiction will love this book, which follows the adventures of three