Cozy Mysteries: Where Comfort Meets Chilling Intrigue and the Paranormal
In the world of mystery novels, there is a genre that offers readers a unique blend of comfort and suspense – cozy mysteries. These books, also known as “cozies,” are the perfect choice for those who want to curl up with a good book, a warm blanket, and a cup of tea while still enjoying the thrill of a good mystery. And in recent years, the cozy mystery genre has seen a rise in popularity, especially with the addition of paranormal and witchy elements. If you are a fan of this genre, or if you are looking for a new book to add to your reading list, here are the top 8+ cozy mystery books for 2025 that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
1. “The Witching Hour” by Sarah Addison Allen
This enchanting novel follows the lives of the Waverley women, who possess magical abilities and a mysterious family history. When a stranger arrives in town, the Waverley family must confront their past and come together to protect their home from a dark force. With a touch of romance and a sprinkle of magic, “The Witching Hour” is a cozy mystery that will keep you captivated until the very end.
2. “A Witch Before Dying” by Heather Blake
In this charming mystery, witch and vintage clothing store owner, Darcy Merriweather, must use her magical powers to solve a murder and clear her friend’s name. With a quirky cast of characters and a small town setting, this book is a perfect blend of humor, romance, and mystery.
3. “Murder, Magic, and Mousse” by Ellie Alexander
The sixth installment in the popular Bakeshop Mystery series, “Murder, Magic, and Mousse” takes readers on a thrilling journey through the world of pastry and witchcraft. When a famous magician is found dead in a local bakery, baker and amateur sleuth, Jules Capshaw, must use her baking skills and her intuition to catch the real killer. With mouth-watering descriptions of baked goods and a touch of the supernatural, this book is a must-read for cozy mystery lovers.
4. “The Ghost and Mrs. McClure” by Alice Kimberly
In this ghostly mystery, bookshop owner Penelope Thornton-McClure must solve a murder with the help of her ghostly companion, Jack Shepard. As they dig deeper into the case, they uncover a web of secrets and lies that will keep readers guessing until the very end. With a charming ghost, a lovable heroine, and a quaint bookstore setting, this book is a delightful addition to the cozy mystery genre.
5. “The Witch of Willow Hall” by Hester Fox
Set in the 1820s, this gothic novel follows the Montrose family as they move to a secluded mansion in the countryside. When strange and supernatural occurrences start happening, the youngest daughter, Lydia, must use her newly discovered powers to protect her family and uncover the truth about their new home. With a hauntingly beautiful atmosphere and a spine-tingling mystery, “The Witch of Willow Hall” is a must-read for fans of both cozy mysteries and the paranormal.
6. “Murder Most Witchy” by Amanda M. Lee
This light-hearted mystery follows the adventures of Bay Winchester, a witch who moves to a small town and inherits a haunted hotel. When a guest is found dead, Bay must use her magical abilities to solve the crime and clear her family’s name. With a lovable cast of characters and a touch of humor, this book is a perfect choice for a cozy night in.
7. “Witch Slapped” by Dakota Cassidy
In this hilarious mystery, witch and bar owner, Blair Wilkes, must solve a murder with the help of her ghostly grandmother and her talking cat. With a fast-paced plot and a witty protagonist, “Witch Slapped” is a perfect read for anyone looking for a cozy mystery with a touch of the supernatural.
8. “The Haunting of Hillwood Farm” by Kathryn Knight
This romantic suspense novel follows the story of Jessa Landry, who inherits a farm with a dark and haunted past. As she struggles to uncover the truth about her family’s history, she must also navigate her growing feelings for the handsome and mysterious caretaker, Gideon.